Federal Indigenous Business Hiring Strategy Faces “Cascading Failure

Date:

A recent report indicates that the federal government’s approach to hiring Indigenous businesses has experienced a “cascading failure,” characterized by inconsistent guidance, insufficient accountability, and inadequate auditing of businesses.

The report, published on Thursday by the Procurement Ombud, identified “systemic gaps” in the contract awarding process under the Procurement Strategy for Indigenous Business, with a significant number of contracts granted without verification of Indigenous eligibility.

The federal initiative aims for five percent of all contracts to be allocated to Indigenous businesses. Procurement Ombud Alexander Jeglic informed CBC Indigenous that this figure serves as a “positive metric” to demonstrate the effectiveness of the strategy.

“Currently, it is portrayed as a success story, but we believe it actually reflects a failure,” Jeglic stated.

The report highlights that the absence of accountability measures complicates the assessment of whether this target is being achieved.

“You cannot confirm how much of that five percent is genuinely benefiting Indigenous businesses,” he remarked.

The review examined the timeframe from April 1, 2023, to March 31, 2025, focusing on Indigenous Services Canada (ISC), Public Services and Procurement Canada (PSPC), Shared Services Canada, Employment and Social Development Canada, and Correctional Services Canada.

To qualify under the strategy, Indigenous businesses must be at least 51 percent Indigenous-owned and controlled, and listed in the Indigenous Business Directory.

The review did not evaluate the management of the Indigenous Business Directory.

Among the 27 contracts reviewed, seven were granted to joint ventures comprising an Indigenous business and a non-Indigenous business, representing 61 percent of the total expenditure.

‘A critical gap’

The report indicates that these contracts were not monitored to ensure they met the necessary work thresholds performed by Indigenous businesses.

“This lack of accountability adversely affects the entire process,” Jeglic stated.

“When there are accusations flying in every direction, yet no one claims responsibility, it is not an effective way to govern.”

ISC is tasked with verifying the eligibility of Indigenous businesses and is required to conduct mandatory audits on any contracts exceeding $2 million. There were 13 contracts that met this criterion, but either departments neglected to request an audit from ISC or ISC was asked but failed to perform one.

“Overall, it represents a complete failure,” Jeglic remarked.

The report asserts that there was no evidence that departments verified whether businesses were included in the Indigenous Business Directory, highlighting “a critical gap in compliance and documentation practices.”

Need for recourse mechanism

The report advocates for the establishment of a recourse mechanism, enabling Indigenous businesses to express concerns regarding the contract awarding process under the strategy.

In response, PSPC affirmed its support for the creation of such a mechanism but delegated the initiative to ISC, which it stated is “best positioned” to collaboratively develop the strategy with Indigenous partners.

ISC representative Pascal Laplante noted that the department appreciates the Ombud’s recommendations and is “taking tangible steps to address” them.

This involves “co-developing policy changes to enhance our practices alongside Indigenous partners, including considering the devolution of responsibility for verifying Indigeneity.”

Source

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

AI Technology Decodes Unique Songs of Ovenbirds for Conservation Insights

From chirps to melodies, birdsong exhibits a range as...

Gatineau Park Leaves Reveal Cold War Nuclear Footprint Until 2024

Although the Cold War officially concluded many years ago,...

Gun Charges Against Sikhs for Justice Leader Stayed Amid Safety Threats

Inderjeet Singh Gosal, the leader of the Sikhs for...

Nicholas Herring Wins 2026 Giller Prize for Groundbreaking Novel

Nicholas Herring has been awarded the 2026 Giller Prize...