Foreign diplomats have been highly praising Prime Minister Mark Carney’s recent speech in Davos, particularly his call for middle powers to unite, which gained significant traction in Europe.
Building on the impact of Carney’s speech, a newly released report ahead of the Munich Security Conference further bolsters his argument and issues a series of stark cautions.
One key warning is that merely showing up is not sufficient for allies; they must bring valuable contributions to the table.
-
Analysis: Is Canada’s Foreign Policy Shifting After Carney’s Speech?
-
Carney Warns of ‘New World Order’ at Davos
The report, a foundational document for the upcoming security conference, emphasizes that alliances now demand continuous investment, credibility, and trust, all of which require active maintenance rather than presumption.
Set to take place in Munich later this week, the conference will delve into how countries that fail to adapt to a more competitive global landscape risk being marginalized in a world increasingly shaped by power dynamics rather than consensus.
The report highlights that the strength of international rules hinges on democratic states willing to defend them.
This assessment hits close to home for Canada, which has long operated under the assumption that the rules-based order would persist, only to find those assumptions challenged by the changing global scenario.
“The new U.S. leadership, historically a champion of the post-1945 international order, now believes that upholding it is no longer in America’s interest,” explained Bunde during a pre-report briefing.
He added, “The U.S. has not only started dismantling it but actively undermining key aspects. This shift was symbolized by the demolition of the White House’s East Wing last year.”
At the previous Munich conference, U.S. Vice-President JD Vance criticized European democracies, suggesting that the real threat to the continent comes from within, a sentiment echoed by Eisentraut who emphasized a global rise of political actors seeking to upend existing institutions.
The report underscores the diminishing impact of middle powers in a world where economic interdependence no longer guarantees stability, and security commitments are increasingly conditional.
Canada, as a middle power, finds itself in a challenging position, a point Carney acknowledged during his Davos address.
“The traditional rules-based international order that benefited countries like Canada is no longer effective,” stated the prime minister.
“We need to recognize the current landscape as a system of escalating power rivalries where economic coercion is a key tool for major powers.”
Declining Influence
The report emphasizes that without tangible capabilities and sustained investment, even well-meaning countries will see their influence dwindle.
“Defending institutions and norms requires actual material power, not just rhetoric,” the report emphasized.
Eisentraut highlighted the growing disillusionment in Western democracies due to the widening gap between rhetoric and action.
She noted, “We are witnessing a period of ‘wrecking ball politics,’ where those advocating for institution destruction are gaining admiration.”
<div class="player-placeholder
