Arguably, there’s no worse entry point into the The Hunger Games series than the latest prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping.
On the surface, this may seem like an exaggerated claim. With five films already released in this young-adult, Battle Royale-inspired saga — four of which detail “girl on fire” Katniss Everdeen’s struggle against the oppressive Capitol regime that forces randomly chosen children into deadly contests — one would think viewers would have a solid understanding of the franchise.
So, as Sunrise on the Reaping takes a step back to recount the story of how a seasoned character previously participated in his own brutal competition, what necessitates such guidance from The Hunger Games?
The answer lies in the intention of its creator. Director Francis Lawrence indicated that crafting Reaping as a genuine entry point for both newcomers and returning fans, regardless of their familiarity with past films, was a primary objective — an effort to create a stand-alone film that is both engaging and entertaining.
This is an ambitious aim — one that Reaping largely achieves as a fairly robust addition to the crowded and often clichéd young adult post-apocalyptic genre.
However, in addressing the second objective, it either outright fails or barely succeeds, resulting in one of the more oddly bleak narratives in the “chosen one” genre.
Rather than showcasing the resilient and often thwarted heroine Katniss, we instead follow the battle-hardened secondary character Haymitch Abernathy — who has long served as a figure of discontent — and are given insight into what made him so intriguingly damaged when he was first introduced to audiences.
This backstory might captivate those who have journeyed with the series from its inception and are eager for more details.
Yet for viewers unfamiliar with the outcomes of the decades-long struggle depicted, Reaping presents a different experience. Its portrayal as a harrowing, almost universally nihilistic narrative for a single character transforms it into a perplexing film when considered independently.
In the original Hunger Games, Haymitch was portrayed by Woody Harrelson as a weathered, traumatized survivor of the games, while Joseph Zada takes on the role here. The story unfolds 24 years prior to the events of the first film, on the brink of what is termed the Second Quarter Quell.
This arcane terminology refers to a significant Hunger Games event, one that viewers familiar with the series know resulted in even greater bloodshed and sorrow than usual — and somehow left an older, angrier Haymitch glaring in outrage when the corrupt government presented him with manipulated, propaganda-laden footage of it in the original film.
For those unaware, however, this film could still conclude with either a heroic triumph or a martyr’s demise.
Such expectations seem plausible as we navigate through the conventional setup: stylized shots of Haymitch promising his love Lenore (Whitney Peak) in a slight Southern drawl that he will never abandon her; Haymitch rescuing her from his fate by selflessly volunteering as “tribute” for his district — the most pitiful and underprivileged district in all of Panem; and his ironic slow clap directed at the indifferent President Snow (Ralph Fiennes), who looks down at the groaning and dying young competitors in the arena below.

Ralph Fiennes as President Snow in a still from The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. (Lionsgate)
These elements serve as expected and effectively executed moral and narrative signposts for the tragic or triumphant storyline. They gain additional narrative depth as the real plot unfolds, with the enigmatic Beetee Latier (Kelvin Harrison Jr.) emerging from the shadows of the arena compound to present Haymitch with a strategy to undermine the Capitol from within, opting to abandon any hope of winning the competition and attempting to thwart the ruling class’s exploitation.
There’s just one hitch: if Haymitch follows through, he won’t survive.
Naturally, since this serves as the backstory for a character who remains alive in subsequent Hunger Games films, this outcome is improbable. However, rather than ruining the experience for those acquainted with the overall conclusion, it merely diminishes it: what was once a compellingly enigmatic and hinted-at trauma in Haymitch’s past devolves into around 30 minutes of chaotic, montage-driven alcoholism and an abundance of tiny coffins, reminiscent of a Dracula-themed dollhouse.
While the overly sentimental depiction of trauma in the latter half of Reaping might harden and simplify existing fans’ understanding of Haymitch, it feels entirely odd for newcomers. Instead of a narrative focused on overcoming fascism — whether genuine, performative, or pyrrhic — we encounter a harsh twist that lacks a coherent emotional framework and clear message.
-
REVIEW
Club Kid is one of TIFF’s best. It might make you cry
-
REVIEW
Ebenezer review: Merry Christmas, Johnny Depp! Is this your comeback yet?
A vague theme surrounding learned helplessness is present — the “implicit submission” of the masses obeying a minority, as explained by philosopher David Hume, as The Hunger Games creator Suzanne Collins has noted. Indeed, the populace in Reaping fails to recognize their potential to resist.
However, aside from a clichéd, hastily tacked-on conclusion — whose emotional impact relies entirely on the assumption that viewers are aware of Katniss Everdeen’s eventual victories — the remainder feels like punishment for the sake of punishment.
The drawn-out, bleak depiction of Haymitch’s seemingly futile existence serves to clarify his later anger — a useful insight for those who eventually watch the first film. But aside from the novelty of a narrative that denies redemption or resolution, little else is offered to newcomers entering the story.
With the true conclusion of Sunrise on the Reaping being The Hunger Games, one might as well begin there. Or perhaps not start at all.
